New York became the first state to pass a heavily modified right-to-repair bill, but a new report reveals that lobbyists, including TechNet representing Apple, Google, and Samsung, influenced the changes made by Gov. Kathy Hochul. The bill aimed to require companies to provide parts, tools, manuals, and diagnostic equipment to independent repair shops and individuals. However, it faced opposition from trade groups, resulting in significant modifications. Lobbyists from TechNet and companies like Apple, Google, and Microsoft met with the governor, with some seeking a veto and others cooperating on changes. TechNet’s suggestions, which aimed to retain manufacturers’ control over the repair market, made their way to the Federal Trade Commission. Despite the revised law being widely expected to pass, state regulators may clarify certain aspects, and advocates hope that New York’s bill will inspire similar debates and legislation in other states.
| Signal | Change | 10y horizon | Driving force |
|---|---|---|---|
| New York passes a modified right-to-repair bill | Legislative change | Increased availability of repair options | Lobbying efforts by tech trade association |
| Lobbyists influenced the bill’s specifics | Influence on legislation | Potential for more industry influence on legislation | Protection of manufacturers’ control over repairs |
| TechNet proposed changes to the bill | Proposed amendments | Limited scope of repairs and safety risk exceptions | Protection of consumer data privacy and safety |
| Revised law expected to be passed in NY | Potential legislative change | Potential for similar laws in other states | Triggering similar debates and laws in other states |
| State regulators may clarify aspects of the law | Regulatory clarification | Improved understanding and enforcement of the law | Ensuring smooth implementation of the law |